Whale Steaks

Whale Steaks
Whale Steaks
This request and recipe originally appeared in the You Asked for It section of the February 1961 issue of Gourmet magazine. It was reprised later in the online series The Way We Cooked Vintage Gourmet. Q I could not locate any recipes for whale steak in your cookbooks. Miss Armida Formichelli Arlington Massachusetts A Mostly because we couldnt locate a whale and still havent. But if you find one we have a recipe.
  • Preparing Time: -
  • Total Time: -
  • Served Person:
Seafood Gourmet

A Culinary Curiosity: Whale Steaks

My grandmother always told me stories about her childhood, tales filled with hardship and resourcefulness. Growing up after the war, food was often scarce. They didn't have the luxury of grocery stores overflowing with exotic choices; they made do with what was available, and that sometimes included the unexpected. This recipe for whale steaks, discovered tucked away in a vintage Gourmet magazine, evokes that spirit of practicality and a touch of adventurousness in the kitchen. It’s a reminder that culinary history is often intertwined with the realities of time and place, a fascinating blend of ingenuity and necessity.

Imagine a time before mass-produced food, when the contents of your dinner plate were more directly linked to the environment around you. The very idea of whale steaks feels oddly anachronistic in our modern world, yet the recipe itself, with its simple steps and familiar techniques, feels oddly comforting. It's not just about the ingredients; it's about the resourcefulness embedded within the instructions. The careful marinating, the tenderizing with a mallet – these aren't glamorous techniques, but they represent a deep understanding of transforming humble ingredients into something delicious.

The process of preparing whale steaks, as described in the old recipe, feels almost ritualistic. The soaking in baking soda, the vinegar marinade, the careful pounding – these actions speak to a respect for the meat, a recognition of its unique texture and the care needed to make it palatable. It reminds me of the way my grandmother treated every morsel of food, her attention to detail reflective of a life where nothing was wasted, and every meal was an occasion of gratitude.

Reading through the instructions, I envision a bustling kitchen, the scent of onions and vinegar mingling with the salt tang of the ocean. The rhythmic thud of the mallet against the meat, a counterpoint to the quiet hum of conversation, paints a vivid picture of domestic life in a bygone era. The final step, the sautéing of the steaks, promises a satisfying sizzle, the taste a curious blend of the familiar and the unknown. It's a taste of history, a window into a different time, a different way of living, and a reminder that culinary innovation often arises from necessity, resourcefulness, and a willingness to embrace the unusual.

While I may never have the opportunity to acquire a whale steak, the recipe itself holds a peculiar fascination. It's a culinary artifact, a tangible piece of a past where the ordinary could be extraordinary, and where even the most unexpected ingredients could be transformed into something delicious.

The enduring appeal of this recipe lies not only in its unusual protagonist but in its simplicity and connection to a bygone era of resourceful cooking. It encourages us to appreciate the ingenuity and creativity of cooks past, even when faced with ingredients we might now consider unusual or unavailable. In a time of abundant food choices, this recipe serves as a potent reminder of the resourcefulness and creativity required in less privileged times.

Perhaps the greatest lesson of this vintage whale steak recipe is the simple act of resourcefulness. It's a lesson that transcends time and circumstance, reminding us that the most fulfilling meals are often those born out of ingenuity and a deep respect for the ingredients before us. It is a reminder to embrace the unexpected and to appreciate the stories hidden within a simple recipe.

Step-by-step

    • To prepare a fresh whale steak for cooking, wash it in a solution of 1 generous tablespoon baking soda to 1 quart water and let it soak for 1 hour.
    • Rinse the meat and marinate it for 2 hours in 3 parts water and 1 part vinegar, with a sliced raw onion.
    • Cut the steak across the grain in slices less than 1/2 inch thick.
    • Sprinkle the slices with lemon juice and pound them with a mallet to tenderize them.
    • Sauté the steaks as you would sliced beefsteak.
    • To use frozen whale meat (and you are more likely to catch it frozen), thaw the meat entirely before washing and marinating it.
    • Braise, stew, or sauté it as you would beef.