Ahh, the simple pleasures of a tuna melt. I like high-end fussy food a lot of the time, but there are times that I enjoy a good old fashioned tuna melt. So sue me.
Ahh, the simple pleasures of a tuna melt. I like high-end fussy food a lot of the time, but there are times that I enjoy a good old fashioned tuna melt. So sue me.
Warm, bubbling American cheese drapes tightly over a thick layer of flaky canned tuna, held up by bread that retains its crunch under high heat. Making this sandwich successfully depends entirely on pre-toasting the bread before adding the wet fish mixture. Without that dry thermal barrier, moisture from the tuna migrates straight into the crumb, turning the slice into a soggy sponge.
Drain the 12-ounce can of tuna thoroughly through a fine-mesh strainer, pressing the flakes against the wire mesh with a spoon to remove excess liquid before introducing the three tablespoons of mayonnaise. Skipping this pressing phase introduces unwanted water content that prevents the cheese from browning properly. Set the oven rack three to four inches away from the broiler element to ensure the top melts evenly without scorching the edges of the whole wheat slices.
Intense overhead heat requires constant visual monitoring during the three to four minute cooking window because dairy proteins burn rapidly once the fats separate. Pull the open-faced sandwiches out immediately when the cheese shows bubbling brown spots and the tuna feels warm throughout. Consuming the sandwiches immediately preserves the textural contrast between the crisp toasted base and the soft topping.